peanut butter and jelly cookies

Did you grow up eating peanut butter and jelly sandwiches in your school lunches?

PBJ Cookies 3 I was more of a plain peanut butter sandwich girl myself.  Actually, I didn’t really like jelly until about high school.  I think it was the texture and the typical grape and strawberry flavors that turned me off to the sweet addition.  Now I love the classic combination, but I much prefer jam or preserves over jelly. Including parts of the fruit just makes it seem a little more natural than just the plain jiggly spread.

PBJ Cookies 6

This weekend I went on a picnic with some friends and wanted to include the pb&j combo without the school lunch sandwich.  Since I am pretty much a cookie fanatic and I already had my favorite preserves on hand from another baking adventure, I took it as a sign that raspberry pb&j cookies must be the answer.

PBJ Cookies 7

Raspberry preserves are the more sophisticated, more mature cousin of regular strawberry jelly.  They transform the classic combination to a more upscale duo, while keeping the nostalgia warranted by any pb&j.

PBJ Cookies 8

Cookies are also the perfect picnic dessert.  They are individual, hand-held and not too messy.  Everyone can have their own without having to cut off a slice with a flimsy plastic knife or trying to balance a paper plate on their lap while their dessert teeter-totters under their fork.  You know what I’m talking about.

PBJ Cookies 9

And really, when are cookies ever a bad idea?  Never.

PBJ Cookies 11

These are soft, chewy and a bit gooey where the cookie meets the preserves.  Unlike the typical thumbprint cookies that just have jelly spooned on top, these have preserves marbleized throughout them.  The perfect nostalgia snack.  While I used raspberry preserves, your favorite jam or jelly would work just as well (I think blackberry or fig would be great).  Now let’s dig in to the tasty throwback!

PBJ Cookies 12

Peanut Butter and Jelly Cookies
makes about 18 cookies

½ cup butter
½ cup creamy peanut butter (not natural, the oil will separate and change the consistency of the dough)
2/3 cup brown sugar
¼ cup sugar
1 egg
1 teaspoon vanilla
1 1/3 cup flour
¼ teaspoon salt
1 teaspoon baking soda
your favorite jam

Preheat oven to 350 degrees.

In the bowl of an electric mixer, cream the butter, peanut butter and sugars together until light and fluffy, about 4 minutes. Add the egg and vanilla and mix until combined. Mix in the flour, baking soda and salt until just until the dry ingredients are incorporated and the dough forms.

Place small balls of dough on a parchment paper covered cookie sheet. Gently press a thumbprint into the dough balls and spoon a small amount of jam in the indention. Crumble additional dough on top of the cookies, completely covering the jam. Bake for 12-14 minutes, or until the tops of the cookies are golden brown.

(Usually I take cookies out of the oven before the tops are brown, since they keep cooking on the tray. These cookies fall apart easily if they are undercooked and are just as soft when they are fully cooked, so be sure to leave them in until the tops turn golden.)

Cookies loosely adapted from here.

Get the Latest


  1. Am a bit confused by the last comments. Should the cookies should appear “golden” or “brown” after 12-14 minutes baking? I get that they’ll be soft if they’re removed early or when fully cooked.

    Also, one of the photos shows the cookies stacked; does that prevent them from falling apart? Am guessing that they’re not the best choice for a cookie gift bag since they’ll probably stick together.


    • Hi! The cookies should be golden, but take them out before they any darker than that to prevent them from burning. The jelly does make them stick together a bit when stacked, but you could put small pieces of parchment paper in between each cookie to gift them and prevent them from sticking together in the stack.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Copyright © 2023 Pass the Cookies · Theme by 17th Avenue